Ever sense I was a kid, I always viewed Halloween as a mini-adventure, a time when kids face their fears, journey out into the night, and share an exciting experience with friends. In a nutshell, Trick or Treat was the event that made Halloween my childhood favorite holiday. Beyond simply collecting candy, it was also the theatrics of dressing in costume, and the excitement of going out into the night that made it so captivating.
By extent, I feel the best Halloween specials are the ones that revolve around the experience of Trick or Treat itself, seeing recognizable characters dress-up, and how their experiences can be viewed as an overnight adventure. Thus, I felt I was long overdue to countdown a list of my own personal Top 10 favorite Trick or Treat specials. As a side note, I won’t be including any movies on this list … so don’t expect any “Hocus Pocus”, “The Halloween Tree” or even the 2007 “Trick R’ Treat” film, this is just a countdown of specials and episodes, which put the focus on Trick or Treat and not just the holiday.
#10 “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Halloween”
As her title suggests, Buffy is no stranger to fighting off dark creatures of the night. However, Halloween night has a distinct power all on its own, and can twist the bravest of vampire slayers into cowards. A mysterious costume shop opens just in time for trick r’ treat, and everyone, including Buffy and her friends all get new costumes. Buffy, feeling a disconnect to her femininity wants to go out as a fair maiden from mid-evil times, while her timed boyfriend goes as a soldier.
In an exciting twist, the costume shop was a trap set by the
villains, and now a curse is unleashed, transforming everyone into what they
dressed as for trick r’ treat. Kids dressed as little monsters become monsters,
Buffy’s closest friend becomes a real ghost, while her boyfriend gets to be a
heroic trooper, and Buffy herself is now a frightened damsel ... making her
easy prey for the real vampires. The concept of becoming what you wear for
Halloween has been done before in “The Simpsons” and “Halloweentown”
movies, but it’s pulled off with great skill here, and turns out a very fun
Halloween venture with our titular vampire slayer.
#9 “Winnie the Pooh: Boo to You Too!”
Way back when I was just a little
boy, this Winnie the Pooh special marked one of my very first Halloween special
experiences, and highlighted Trick or Treat as an adventure in concurring one’s
fears. While nothing supernatural happens, Winnie the Pooh, Piglet and friends still
made this an exciting night out, as their imaginations run wild, and bring
about all kinds of spooky fun. From the opening title sequence, this animated special
captures a magical sense of the holiday, as it’s both eerie and ominous, yet
still enticing and engaging. It may be slight stuff, but for me, this was a
special animated trick or treating experience from my childhood, and I just had
to include it.
#8 “Hotel Transylvania: The Legend of Pumpkin Guts”
2017 marked the premier of a 2D animated “Hotel Transylvania” TV series, which focuses on Dracula’s daughter Mavis during her younger teenage years at the hotel. The franchise already had a heavy lean on Halloween … but “The Legend of Pumpkin Guts” is the special one to bring Trick or Treat into the mix. In a clever twist, Halloween night is a dangerous time for monsters, but Mavis and company are eager to venture out, and discover the joy of trick or treating.
Participating in a human pass time for Halloween
is where all the trouble comes in, as it unleashes a giant pumpkin creature
hellbent on transforming all other monsters into Jack O’ Lanterns. It’s about
as crazy as it sounds, but still kind of clever, and bursting with decorative
Halloween animation. Beyond that, it’s the novelty of monster characters
dressing up for Trick or Treat that makes this stand out with its own unique
spin and personality.
#7 “Wishbone: The Legend of Sleepy Hollow”
Another childhood staple of mine, Wishbone was a dog who introduced kids to classic literature, as he imagined himself taking on the likeness of characters from the source material. Halloween brings on thoughts of Legend of Sleepy Hollow, in which Wishbone takes on the likeness of Ichabod Crane. For a kid’s program, it doesn’t change too much of the tale, including the dark ending in which the lead character mysteriously disappears, and even the image of the Headless Horsman is quiet striking.
Meanwhile, as Wishbone relays the story, his owners are naturally out in costume, and trick or treat takes on a new twist as a scavenger hunt, leading to an exciting venture into a spooky house. It’s shot and lit like any
great spooky outing, and there’s even some effective creepy imagers for a
program of its target audience. Naturally it’s still on the level of a kid’s
program, but still a very fun trick or treat venture to experience at a young
age, and to look back on as an adult with great fondness.
#6 “DuckTales: The Trickening”
Scrooge McDucks four kids Huey, Dewey, Webby, and Louie set-off to go trick r’ treating, only for Louie to lead the group into a haunted house, where he thinks he’ll find mountains of candy left behind by frightened kids. Naturally, the house is haunted, and the kids find themselves trapped, with a number of horrific obstacles threatening to scare them … to death.
The premise of combining trick or treat with a haunted house venture is a winning formula, and this special manages to transcend its premise, by giving it more twists and turns, and with a slightly dark edge. Turns out the haunts were all staged by the classic monsters in the vein of the Wereduck, Witch Hazel, Nosferatu, and Frankenstein, who’ve lost the ability to scare kids, and thus are resorting to contemporary scares.
It becomes a fun game of “name that horror movie”, with visual references to “Poltergeist”, “The Ring”, Steven Kings “IT”, “Dead Silence”, and especially “The Shining” … which is utilized brilliantly in the final shot. This is also a gorgeous looking episode, with phenomenal details, atmospheric lighting, twisted angels, and elaborate backdrops. It’s a solid, spooky Halloween adventure that packs all the wright chills, visuals, and laughs in one tight package.
#5 “Garfield’s Halloween Adventure”
Garfield’s never-ending love for sweets entices him and his buddy Odie to go out Trick or Treating on Halloween night, and as the title suggests … the night turns into quiet the adventure. They discover monster costumes are real monsters in disguise, they get lost on the river, venture into a spooky house, discover pirate gold, and get chased by ghost pirates. This completes a special animated Halloween trilogy of sorts for me, with Charlie Browns “Great Pumpkin” being my first, then Winnie the Pooh’s “Boo to you Too!” being my second, and finally, “Garfield’s Halloween Adventure” was the third big trick or treating special from my childhood.
It had the same laid-back charm,
and warm holiday atmosphere of the previous two, but this time, the adventure raised
the stakes, with characters getting lost, and having supernatural encounters. It’s
great stuff, with Garfield’s pirate costume feeling as iconic as any holiday
mascot, and the special is a fitting example of Trick or Treat taking on a life
of its own as an all-night Halloween adventure.
#4 “Goosebumps: The Haunted Mask”
Back when I was a kid, “Goosebumps” was hands down my favorite “Spooky Themed” TV program, and featured a number of episodes that became personal staples for Halloween. The big one being “The Haunted Mask”, which put a new spin on Trick or Treat, and the dangers that come with putting on a new face. Young Carly Beth can’t go anywhere without being picked on by either bullies or family members, and now she’s out for revenge. Desperate, she steals a Halloween mask from a new Spirit Store, against the storekeeper's warnings. However, the mask begins to change her personality and melds with her body when she wears it.
Clearly,
she got more than she bargained for, as she’s now taking on the appearance of a
living monster, leading into an internal battle to see if the real person can
break free from this monstrous new form. There’s just something about the look
and feel of this episode that’s always stuck with me as eerie, yet exciting,
and even thoughtful in its resolution. It’s just a classic “Goosebumps”
venture, with a memorable center villain, and it has a great premise to go
along with Trick or Treat.
#3 Donald Duck: “Trick Or Treat!”
Our favorite Disney Ducks are back for another Halloween treat, and for me, it’s just as much a classic as Charlie Browns “Great Pumpkin” special. When Donald Duck cruelly mistreats his nephews, a kind old Witch named Hazel comes to their aid, and gives them a healthy dose of ... Trick or Treat! Old Witch Hazel is one of the most memorable guest characters from the Disney cartoon roster, and her hex casting antics lead to some bouncy animation highlights.
The catchy “Trick or Treat”
theme song alone makes this one of the best of these specials. The animation,
like I said, is just bursting with memorable holiday visuals. It's neither the
darkest, nor spookiest of Disney shorts ... but it's the one that I love watching the most around this time of year. A lot of people say that 1968’s “It’s the
Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown” is what really started the notion of classic
animated Halloween specials, but look at this short, which came out almost a
decade before it, and is just swimming with holiday delights.
#2 “Gravity Falls: Summerween”
While the show is set during the summertime, the people of Gravity Falls love the holiday so much that they celebrate it twice, and one of the events is during the summer, in which it’s lovingly called “Summerween”. That premise alone is ingenious and makes me wish I could have grown up in that town. As the episode continues, we see that one of the shows lead child hero’s named Dipper is ready to grow up, and spend the holiday with the older guys as opposed to Trick or Treating with his sister Mable.
This causes a rift between the two as Mable wants to savor every Trick or Treat she can with her brother before they become teenagers. To make matters worse, the kids are soon chased by a deadly entity called The Trickster, who threatens to harm all who don’t keep the holiday spirit alive. The details in this episode are great as it creates a perfect Halloween atmosphere, as well as the personality of any special I’d watch yearly around the season.
Naturally, it puts trick r’ treating front in center,
and makes it feel like more of an adventure than the majority of the specials
I’ve mentioned. It’s a special that just seems to combine everything I love in
one perfect package, including nostalgic childhood ties to the season, a mythos
surrounding a mysterious creature, a sweet sibling story, thrilling monster
action and no shortage of funny jokes.
Before I
reveal my number one favorite, here are some quick Honorable Mentions …
“Ed, Edd N’ Eddy: Boo-Haw Haw”
“Monsters vs. Aliens: Mutant Pumpkins from Outer Space”
“The Simpsons: I've Grown a Costume on Your Face”
“A Pup Named Scooby-Doo: Ghost who's Coming to Dinner”
“Season’s Greetings” (1996)
#1 “It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown”
As Far back as I can remember, this was the very first Halloween special I ever saw, and naturally, whenever I think of Trick or Treat, it’s Charlie Brown and the gang in their costumes that always seems to spring to mind first. For this outing, things are as simple as they get, with a group of kids going out Trick or Treating, followed by a party … and that’s it. There are no stakes, no supernatural oddities, not even a real sense of excitement, and I think that’s why it’s made such a lasting connection with viewers over the years.
Without question, it’s the most grounded and relatable Halloween special, and just seems to capture something special that many of us can either relate to or identify with. It’s hard to describe what makes a special a classic, but it’s also easy to just watch this group of kids doing everything we associate with October, from carving a Jack’ O’ Lanterns, to trick or treating, to making individual costumes, to Halloween parties, and it’s all so genuine, nostalgic, memorable, and for me has a secure spot as my favorite Trick or Treat special.
Thanks for
reading my countdown … and continue to enjoy the holiday specials you Love!
HAPPY HALLOWEEN!