Even though I’ve always had my own opinion on films and have always wanted to share them with others, my inspiration for reviewing films came from other popular reviewers like Siskel and Ebert. But my biggest influences came from Internet reviews like “Confused Mathew” or “Cinemassacre” and a personal favorite of mine has always been the “Nostalgia Critic” from “That Guy with the Glasses. Com”. This show’s sort of a fun mix between film reviewing and a laugh out loud comedy show. He focuses on old films that he grew up with, preferably the bad ones because he can be as silly and as funny as he wants with those. Then occasionally, he’ll review something positive from his past and those are the ones that inspire me to review movies and shows that I grew up with. Whether it’s one of his funny reviews or his honestly nostalgic reviews, this show was a lot of fun to watch and now after roughly five years on the internet, this show has reached its final episode. So to celebrate, here are my personal, top 11 favorite Nostalgia Critic episodes. Why top 11, because every single list of his was a top 11 list and in order to do a proper tribute, I’m going to have to make this a top 11 list as well.
11. NC reviews "Casper"
Over all the years of funny Nostalgia Critic Halloween reviews, nothing has quiet stuck with me more then his early review of “Casper”. The movie itself was an okay film that I grew up with, but didn't really think there was enough material in the film to make a very funny review out off. Well, not only do the jokes in this review work, but there some of his most memorable stabs at a spooky family film. The joke that makes this episode stand out is that a cartoon Casper is constantly picking at the Critic for reviewing his film, which is something we'd never seen before from his video's. This leads to one of his greatest climaxes ever where the Nostalgia Critic suits up in a Ghostbusters costume, battles the Casper cartoon, chases him down the street to a video game expo, and then has a full mob of costumed people behind him. This was his first time he appeared at a convention of any sort, and he definitely made a big splash ... quiet literally as it ends with him diving into a pool. At the time, it was one of the funniest things I'd ever seen on the internet, and while the critic still continues to make me laugh after all these years, there was just something special and unique about the comedy in this review that makes it my personal favorite Nostalgia-Ween review.
10. AVGN VS. NC: The Final Battle (in 2 parts)
Aside from reviewing movies and constructing top 11 lists, sometimes the Nostalgia Critic will just have a random, special episode with guest characters and odd, comedic storytelling. One of his best long running specials was in the very first season of the show, where he was literally at war with another popular comedic, internet character called the Angry Video Game Nerd. This was a fun little running joke that these two had a grudge against each other but the highlight was the last episode, simply titled “The Final Battle”. It’s just this crazy one on one fight between these two over the top, comedic guys, with lots of flashy effects, lots of really quick jokes and it was such of fun conclusion to this running series of episodes.
9. NC reviews "The NeverEnding Story III: Escape to Fantasia"
This was one of those movies that I grew up with and hated with a passion, so it was great fun to see the Nostalgia Critic expose this film for the unbelievably terrible movie that it is. The jokes are all really funny, especially some new cartoony jokes, like the Critics jaw cartoonishly dropping to the floor at the shock of just how bad the film gets. It’s one of those bad movies that he can really have a lot of fun with and it all leads to the biggest breakout of rage as he literally destroys a DVD copy of the movie with a crowbar.
8. "Batman" (1989) VS. "The Dark Knight"
His old vs. new episodes are terrific specials where he compares an original movie to its remake or reimagining and my favorite is his comparison of the original “Batman” to “The Dark Knight”. His comparisons between the two films are interesting, he brings up a couple of things from the original that I had never really considered before and it’s always fun to have a big Batman themed video. Even though I didn’t agree with opinion on which of these two is better, I still thought his explanations were good and it had me consistently interested in what he had to say.
7. NC’s Top 11 Underrated Nostalgic Classics
One of his best top 11 reviews by far because this one really takes me back to my childhood and it’s such a rare treat to see the Nostalgia Critic put aside all the silly jokes and honestly come forth with a discussion on old films that he feels deserve more attention. While I don’t exactly agree with all the films on this list, I certainly agree with most of them, especially the film at number 1 on this list and it’s also just a really nice treat to look over all these great films that people hardly ever notice. It’s warm, it’s cheerful and it perfectly lives up to the title of Nostalgia.
6. The Return of the Nostalgic Commercials: "We'll Be Right Back..."
This was part of a trilogy of episodes where the Nostalgia Critic literally just looks at odd and silly commercials that we grew up with as kids and it’s such a joy to see just how funny some of these advertisements can get. Personally, it was this middle episode titled “We’ll Be Right Back” that had me laughing the most. This one had all the really funny commercials to look at like the “Bubble Thing” product and this crazy kid that loves Nerf guns. But the big advertisement that steals this special is the “Wonder Boner” advertisement, I can’t even express in words how funny that was. Overall, his commercial specials where an absolute joy to watch and it was this middle episode that easily stands as one of the NC’s best experiences.
5. NC reviews "Pokémon: The First Movie"
I’ll always regard the first Pokémon movie as one of the absolute worst experiences of my child hood, even as a kid this film sucked the big one. Honestly, of all the bad movies that the Nostalgia Critic reviewed, there was no greater joy then seeing him bash this film. The jokes he makes in this review are brilliant, the delivery is great, and this was actually one of his very first episodes that got me hooked into watching the show. A lot of his early reviews were really good because they were all for fun, without as much screaming and yelling. But it’s this review that I’ll always regard as his best, classic review.
4. That Guy With The Glasses: Team Brawl
Now this was something special, at the end of his very first year on the website, the NC celebrates by giving us this mega episode with all these different characters and reviews from his website and other sites getting together for this ridicules epic battle. At the time, I never would have expected to see something this big, this crazy and this over the top on an internet show. There are lots of crazy effects, lots of fun slapstick fighting and lots of terrific guest characters, including the Angry Video Game Nerd, who had one last fight with the NC. It’s too good to be real and it was just too fun to have for just one year, that’s why at the end of every season, there’d be another yearly anniversary episode that brought all these silly internet characters together.
3. The complete Disneycember Marathon
By the time his last season came around, a lot of his reviews were just becoming stupid and even a bit unwatchable. But then in December 2011, he does something outstanding called Disneycember. This was a series of short reviews of every single classic animated Disney movie and this time, he reviewed them as himself (Doug Walker) as opposed to the Nostalgia Critic character. I’m a big fan of classic animated Disney movies and while I didn’t agree with every opinion of his regarding some of these films, it still felt like one of the most truly Nostalgic things he’s ever done. I loved listening to his honest opinions of all these classic movies, I loved how short and simple they were and I’ve actually always wanted someone to just go down the list of every traditional animated Disney movie and share their thoughts on them, so this was like a mini dream come true for me.
2. NC’s Top 11 Coolest Clichés
This is my favorite of his top 11 lists because it really felt like a celebration of things that we love to see in movies. There are hardly any jokes or rants, it’s just a perfectly loving tribute to the stuff we enjoy in film and it’s a rare case in which I agreed with just about everything he listed. It’s just a really fun video and it’s the one NC episode that I find myself re-watching the most.
1. Suburban Knights (The 3 Year Anniversary Special in 7 parts)
Unlike the first year anniversary, which was just one big, fun, fight, this third year anniversary was an epic little comedy adventure that spanned over seven parts. The premise goes like this, the Nostalgia Critic and his team of reviewers from his website dress up as classic fantasy characters from movies and video games, they then head out on a hilarious and relatively exciting little adventure filled with lots of fun battle scenes, crazy jokes, great music, nice little character moments, including some hilarious new characters and an awesome villain character. The story is surprisingly competent for an internet made movie and while other yearly anniversaries would be a comedic adventure, they never reached the same highlights that this special has to offer. I love the whole medieval adventure theme, the passing is great and it just seems to feature every great thing that the Nostalgia Critic has to offer.
Runner Up’s include: Doug's Top 10 Movies He Likes But Everybody Else Hates, NC’s Moonwalker review, To Boldly Flee: 8 part series, Batman and Robin review, all other Halloween reviews, Tom and Jerry: The Movie Review, all Christmas Reviews, Howard the Duck review, Every other Old Vs. New, Top 11 Villain Songs, The Room review, Animaniacs Tribute, NC’s Top 11 Drug PSAs, Top 11 Dumbest Spider-Man Moments, The Wizard review, The Langoliers review and NC’s Top 11 Batman The Animated Series Episodes.
Biggest Laugh out Loud Moments
As an extra bonus, here are my top ten biggest laugh out loud moments from the Nostalgia Critic episodes.
11. Girls mud fighting from the NC’s review of “Mortal Kombat: Annihilation”
10. Non-censored Duck from the NC’s review of “Howard the Duck”
9. Mara Wilson’s cameo from the NC’s review of “A Simple Wish”.
8. Captain Planet educating kids about Aids from the NC’s review of “Captain Planet”.
7. Chasing down Casper from the NC’s review of “Casper”.
6. Pee-Wee Herman’s drug PSA from the NC’s Top 11 Drug PSA’s
5. Zack Morris over the top costume in the NC’s review of “Saved by the Bell”.
4. The “Bat Credit Card” gag from the NC’s review of “Batman and Robin”.
3. Reacting to Tommy Wiseau’s bad acting from the NC’s review of “The Room”.
2. The Wonder boner advertisement from the NC’s second commercial special.
1. Baby Arnold Schwarzenegger from the NC’s review of “Junior”.